When the Board Lets AI Write the Rules

In June 2026, homeowners packed a Foothills Club West HOA board meeting in Ahwatukee, Arizona, to protest new parking rules scheduled to take effect within weeks. Board members acknowledged using artificial intelligence (AI) to help develop the rules, which the board ultimately rescinded following homeowner backlash. 

The incident highlights a potential liability exposure for HOA boards. Board members remain responsible for the policies they approve, regardless of whether AI helped draft them. Adopting rules without adequate review could lead to homeowner disputes and allegations of mismanagement or breach of fiduciary duty. HOA board education should therefore address how to evaluate AI-generated policies for accuracy, compliance with governing documents, and potential legal concerns before approving them.

What Went Wrong in Ahwatukee

Board members’ own accounts show how the draft got past them. A board member explained the AI-generated document expanded from a dozen points to multiple pages, leaving the board with many more provisions to review. The board president called trusting AI to write the rules one of the mistakes, and the board plans to put community input first on future policies.

A management company representative gave a different account, saying the rules were applied to the master policy through a clerical error. Under either account, the rules reached owners before anyone caught the problem. A board client using AI faces the same gap unless its process includes a review step.

How California’s Rule-Change Process Catches a Bad Draft

California requires boards to get owner input before adopting or changing rules on certain subjects. Agents with California board clients can use that process to show where review catches a flawed draft.

Section 4355 applies the notice process to rules on listed subjects, including common area use and member fines. A parking rule for association streets would fall under common area use. For those rules, § 4360 requires the board to give owners at least 28 days’ notice of a proposed change, with its text and a description of its purpose and effect. The board then decides at a board meeting after considering member comments. Treated as an HOA communication strategy, the notice period puts an AI draft in front of owners who may catch errors the board missed.

Where an AI Draft Fails California’s Enforceability Tests

Notice alone doesn’t make a rule valid. Under § 4350, an operating rule is valid and enforceable only if it meets five requirements. The rule must be in writing, fall within the board’s authority, avoid conflict with governing law and the governing documents, and be reasonable. The board must also adopt it in good faith and in substantial compliance with the required process. An AI draft can fail four of those tests:

  • Authority: A draft that regulates more than the CC&Rs or bylaws allow falls outside the board’s authority.
  • Conflict: An invented legal requirement can put the rule in conflict with governing law.
  • Process: A board that adopts the draft without the 28-day notice fails the substantial-compliance requirement.
  • Reasonableness: A draft that grows the way the Ahwatukee document did can add restrictions the board never weighed.

A rule that fails any test isn’t enforceable. If the association fines an owner under it, the owner has grounds to challenge the rule, targeting the board’s decision to adopt it.

Inaccurate AI information is one of the board risks KDIS will cover in its webinar, “Before You Trust AI: Understand Your D&O Exposure as a Community Association Board Member or Manager,” on Nov. 19, 2026, at 11 a.m. PT. Register for the webinar.

Why a Rule Challenge Lands on the D&O Policy

An owner challenging a rule under § 4350 seeks to have the rule eliminated, so the owner would likely ask a court to block its enforcement or declare it invalid. Neither request seeks money, which makes the claim non-monetary. A D&O policy limited to monetary claims can leave the board exposed because it may not respond to a suit seeking no damages. The board could then face defense costs without coverage.

KDIS’s D&O policy covers monetary and non-monetary claims. For a board client insured under it, coverage may respond to a rule challenge. Before a board client adopts new rules, agents should confirm that its D&O policy’s definition of a claim includes non-monetary relief.

Oversight Steps Before Any AI-Drafted Rule Is Adopted

Each § 4350 test points to a step agents can pass to board clients before a vote:

  • Counsel check: Have the association’s attorney verify every law the draft cites, which catches invented requirements before they create a conflict.
  • Scope check: Compare each provision with the CC&Rs and bylaws to confirm the board has authority over it.
  • Reasonableness check: Have board members read every provision the AI added and cut any they can’t justify.
  • Owner notice: Send owners a redline with a plain-language description of the change’s purpose and effect, which also meets § 4360’s notice content in California.
  • Comment review: Read member comments before the vote, and record that the board considered them.

Agents can extend the same HOA board education to other board decisions that rely on AI answers. To place D&O coverage for a board client, download KDIS’s applications or contact KDIS.

About the Author

Kevin Davis is President of Kevin Davis Insurance Services, Inc. (KDIS) and managing general agent for Travelers Insurance — one of the largest specialty insurance writers for community associations in the United States, currently insuring more than 40,000 associations nationwide. With three decades in the insurance industry — 25 of them devoted exclusively to community associations — Davis brings rare depth of expertise to a highly specialized field. He founded KDIS in 2000 with a two-person team and has since built it into a firm of more than 65 employees, establishing the company as a trusted leader in its market. A nationally recognized authority on loss prevention, Davis writes and speaks regularly on the subject. He also serves as a faculty member for Community Associations Institute (CAI) training programs throughout the country.

About Kevin Davis Insurance Services

For over 35 years, Kevin Davis Insurance Services has built an impressive reputation as a strong wholesale broker offering insurance products for the community association industry. Our president, Kevin Davis, and his team take pride in offering committed services to the community association market and providing them with unparalleled access to high-quality coverage, competitive premiums, superior markets, and detailed customer service. To learn more about the coverage we offer, contact us toll-free at (855) 790 -7393 to speak with one of our representatives.